Discretion

What Discretion means in a networked world

A private message explains why a volunteer missed a meeting. In the public argument about the empty chair, you start attaching the exchange as proof. Then you notice that your evidence would also publish someone else’s family circumstances. You remove the attachment and ask the volunteer what, if anything, they want conveyed. The screenshot was ready to bring the entire household to a meeting they never joined.

Discretion considers who becomes exposed when information changes audience. An exchange entrusted to you can include facts about people who never agreed to take part. Begin with the purpose of disclosure: what does this audience need to understand, and who should decide how a personal account travels? Sometimes a permitted summary conveys the relevant point; sometimes the person prefers to speak for themselves or leave the matter private. A withheld screenshot need not mean a withheld concern. Necessary reporting can use an appropriate route without making a private life public evidence for everyone.

Discretion gives…

Careful handling makes trust usable. People can explain a difficulty, ask for help and cooperate without every confidence becoming material for the next argument. A clear, limited account can also keep the public discussion on the decision it actually needs to make.

Finding the balance

In ordinary life

A helpful explanation

Ask before passing a colleague’s private explanation to another group. Permission to quote one sentence does not include the whole conversation.

A cropped image

A missing name does not guarantee anonymity: a date, place or distinctive event may identify the person. Consider whether the image needs to travel at all.

Nearby virtues, different work

Candor

Candor communicates relevant truth. Discretion judges the audience and scope so that a truthful account does not expose unrelated private facts.

Attentiveness

Attentiveness notices the family details inside the evidence. Discretion decides how those details should be handled.

Recognizing a counterfeit

Protecting a reputation at any cost counterfeits Discretion. Privacy does not settle whether wrongdoing should be reported; it shapes how necessary information reaches the people equipped to address it.

How to cultivate Discretion

• Distinguish permission to receive from permission to redistribute.
• Identify everyone described in an exchange, including people outside it.
• Ask what the intended audience needs before choosing what to convey.

Try it today

Before forwarding a private exchange, pause and identify whose circumstances would become visible. Leave it unforwarded while you consider permission, a limited summary or an appropriate reporting route. Removing names alone is no guarantee of privacy.

Questions worth returning to

• What changes when this audience receives the exchange?
• Whose permission have I assumed?

Choose your practice

These pages offer ideas for reflection and character practice, not professional advice. Choose practices suited to your circumstances and abilities. You may adapt, pause, or skip an exercise; putting yourself or someone else at risk is not proof of virtue.

Quotations and further reading

Seven selections to return to through the week. Follow a source link to read the surrounding passage.

1. for who will open himself to a blab or a babbler?

   Francis Bacon, Bacon’s Essays
   Essay VI, Of Simulation and Dissimulation, account of secrecy

   The blunt question connects thoughtless disclosure with a loss of confidence. Handling a private detail carefully can leave people freer to contribute what they choose.

2. I requested Webb not to mention it; but he told it to Keimer, who immediately, to be beforehand with me, published proposals for printing one himself, on which Webb was to be employ’d.

   Benjamin Franklin, Autobiography
   Autobiography, the proposed newspaper

   A detail entrusted to one person can change another person’s opportunities when repeated. Before forwarding, consider what the changed audience can do with it.

3. Here have we been, the whole winter and spring, completely duped, fancying ourselves all on an equal footing of truth and honour, with two people in the midst of us who may have been carrying round, comparing and sitting in judgment on sentiments and words that were never meant for both to hear.

   Emma Woodhouse, in Jane Austen, Emma
   Volume III, chapter X, Emma on the secret engagement

   Emma objects to words reaching an audience their speakers did not know they had. A private exchange can change meaning and consequences when carried elsewhere.

4. When Peter has thus effectually launched a Secret, I have been very well pleased to hear People whispering it to one another at second Hand, and spreading it about as their own; for you must know, Sir , the great Incentive to Whispering is the Ambition which every one has of being thought in the Secret, and being look'd upon as a Man who has Access to greater People than one would imagine.

   The fictional projector, in Joseph Addison, The Spectator
   No. 457, Thursday, August 14, 1712

   Peter Hush’s listeners pass his secret on as their own discovery. The wish to appear well connected can carry private information far beyond its first audience.

5. there was time also to rejoice that Harriet’s secret had not escaped her, and to resolve that it need not, and should not.

   Narrator of Emma, in Jane Austen, Emma
   Volume III, chapter XIII, Emma receiving Knightley’s declaration

   Emma can protect Harriet’s confidence even amid her own excitement. Another person’s private feeling need not become part of your public explanation.

6. I can scarcely believe, when I recollect my own practice, that I could have been so far deluded with petty praise, as to divulge the secrets of trust, and to expose the levities of frankness; to waylay the walks of the cautious, and surprise the security of the thoughtless.

   The former wit, a fictional narrator, in Samuel Johnson, The Rambler
   No. 174. SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 1751.

   Johnson’s narrator looks back on the praise that tempted him to betray confidences. An appreciative audience does not make another person’s private life yours to circulate.

7. At the same Time I am very sensible, that nothing spreads a Paper like private Calumny and Defamation; but as my Speculations are not under this Necessity, they are not exposed to this Temptation.

   Joseph Addison, The Spectator
   No. 16, Monday, March 19, 1711

   Addison recognizes that private scandal sells a paper and declines to make it his business. Before passing a message on, notice whose exposure would make it interesting.

Continue through the catalog