Universal Virtues
Integrity
Let a considered principle govern the convenient exception.
During an imagined table game, a player receives a shiny token that belongs to an unfinished move. Nobody has noticed. The player slides it back and completes the move properly. The token becomes less impressive; the rules become more trustworthy.
Understanding Integrity
Integrity keeps deliberate action consistent with considered ethical convictions. Its difficulty often appears in a small exception that would benefit the person making it. Consistency matters because the principle has a defensible purpose; remaining loyal to a cruel or mistaken rule is not integrity.
Read this collection’s historical contextIntegrity: finding the balance
The player receives an unearned token.
Too little of the fitting response
Convenient inconsistency
The player pockets the token and continues policing other players’ turns.
A fitting response
Considered integrity
The player returns it and follows the agreed move.
A distortion of the purpose
Rigid rule worship
The player refuses any discussion of an obviously mistaken rule because change would look inconsistent.
A sound principle deserves fidelity; a mistaken principle deserves reconsideration.
Integrity gives…
Others can rely on a commitment that holds when a shortcut would be discreet. The person acting can also explain the decision without inventing a special exemption. Integrity gives a principle practical weight at the point where it becomes inconvenient.
What Integrity makes possible
An agreed standard can shape a calculation, an allocation or a promise even when nobody is inspecting the result. If the standard itself needs correction, integrity can support explaining why and changing it openly rather than quietly taking the personal advantage first.
Integrity in ordinary life
- Correct a routine credit that you know you have not earned.
- Apply the agreed criterion to your own contribution before using it to judge someone else’s.
- When a rule is unfair, propose a transparent revision rather than a private exception for yourself.
Nearby virtues, different work
Honesty avoids misleading representations. Fairness gives relevant interests their due. Bravery faces fear. Integrity concerns fidelity in action to a considered ethical commitment; it can be tested even when there is no audience and little fear.
Integrity and its counterfeits
Selective principle is a counterfeit of Integrity: the player insists on correct turns for everyone else while keeping the unearned token. Genuine integrity applies the same considered standard to the convenient case. Unthinking rigidity is another counterfeit; consistency does not make a harmful principle sound.
How to cultivate Integrity
Notice the sentence “This time is different” when the difference chiefly benefits you. State the principle and ask whether the reason for an exception could be explained to everyone affected. Reconsider the principle when relevant reasons challenge it.
Try it today
In an ordinary low-stakes task, check whether you are allowing yourself a shortcut you would reasonably reject in another person. Correct it if appropriate, or identify a defensible reason for a consistent exception.
Keep the practice proportionate
Respect confidentiality, privacy and safety. Integrity does not require public confession, total disclosure or confrontation with an unsafe authority. Choose a bounded task freely.
A question worth returning to
What principle did the exception serve, and what convenience did it hide?
Quotations and further reading
These historical passages offer different philosophical and literary perspectives. Each note identifies its setting, point of comparison and relevant limits; none supplies an official definition of this strength.
Anyhow, however it be done, unless people care about carrying on their business without making the world hideous, how can they care about Art?
William Morris · Hopes and Fears for Art
p. 1THE LESSER ARTS [1]
Morris challenges the separation between caring about art and the effects of ordinary business on the visible world.
But is utility the only creed which is able to furnish us with excuses for evil doing, and means of cheating our own conscience?
John Stuart Mill · Utilitarianism
CHAPTER II.
Mill asks whether any ethical creed is uniquely able to excuse wrongdoing. The challenge is directed at selective criticism and self-exemption.
SOME, in their discourse, desire rather commendation of wit, in being able to hold all arguments, than of judgment, in discerning what is true; as if it were a praise, to know what might be said, and not, what should be thought.
Francis Bacon · The Essays or Counsels, Civil and Moral
Of Discourse
Bacon distinguishes showing off the ability to argue from discerning what is true. Verbal versatility can become a counterfeit of judgment.
No virtue assists itself with falsehood; truth is never matter of error.
CHAPTER VI——USE MAKES PERFECT · Charles Cotton translation, William Carew Hazlitt edition, 1877
Montaigne defends an accurate account of oneself against both exaggeration and false self-depreciation. Integrity can tell the truth about an achievement without either inflating or denying it.
The bass and treble strings of our duty are only bonds so long as we cannot maintain them steadfastly attuned according to the law of truth; and we cannot call by the name of freedom the loosening of them into the nothingness of inaction.
Rabindranath Tagore · Sadhana: The Realisation of Life
REALISATION IN ACTION · Linked 1916 Macmillan text; first publication 1913. Chapter VI translated by Surendra Nath Tagore; other English translation contributions acknowledged in the preface.
Tagore compares duties to tuned strings, distinguishing freedom from mere inaction. Consistency involves maintaining a relation between commitments and conduct.
Now fortune does not give virtue; therefore she does not take it away.
Lucius Annaeus Seneca · Minor Dialogues Together with the Dialogue on Clemency
THE SECOND BOOK OF THE DIALOGUES22 OF L. ANNAEUS SENECA, ADDRESSED TO SERENUS. “THAT THE WISE MAN CAN NEITHER RECEIVE INJURY NOR INSULT,” OR, AN ESSAY ON THE FIRMNESS OF THE WISE MAN. · Aubrey Stewart, 1889
Seneca distinguishes virtue from the gifts of fortune. A lucky token is not evidence that its recipient has earned the turn.
A virtue of honesty, or chastity or benevolence which lives upon itself apart from definite results consumes itself and goes up in smoke.
John Dewey · Human Nature and Conduct
III · ,
Dewey asks that virtues answer to definite results instead of consuming themselves in isolation. Keeping a rule includes examining what the action actually does.
Continue through Universal Virtues
About this educational readingPractice this collection
The optional workbook uses contemporary adaptations. Original historical wording and quotations remain on the reading pages.
Explore the contemporary practice program · Choose in My Virtues